All Articles

Exam Technique

How to Answer Poetry Contextual Questions

By Kate · · 4 min read

Contextual questions are where many marks are won and lost in the poetry section. They look short and manageable, which tempts learners to answer quickly and vaguely. Yet each question is testing something specific, and a precise answer of three sentences will usually do better than a rambling paragraph. Here is how I teach learners to approach them.

Read the question twice, and underline the instruction

The most common reason for losing marks is not a lack of knowledge but answering a different question from the one asked. Before you write anything, underline the key instruction word and the specific focus. "Explain the effect of the simile" is not the same as "Discuss the speaker's attitude", even if both refer to the same lines.

Question verbs matter. "Identify" asks you to name something; "explain" asks you to show how or why; "discuss" or "comment" asks for a more developed response that may include your own evaluation. There is a full breakdown in Discuss, Explain, Comment: Decoding Question Verbs.

Use the mark value as a guide to length

Look at how many marks the question carries. As a general rule, each mark usually needs a distinct, relevant point. A one-mark question may need only a word or a phrase. A question carrying more marks needs a developed answer: a point, a piece of evidence and an explanation, sometimes more than once. Always check your school's or the IEB's current guidelines, but the principle holds: do not write a paragraph for one mark, and do not write one line when several are clearly expected.

The basic structure of a strong answer

For most questions that ask about language, imagery or tone, this pattern works well:

  1. Make your point directly, using the words of the question.
  2. Support it with a brief quotation, just a few words.
  3. Explain how those words create the effect you have described.
  4. Where appropriate, link back to the poem's wider meaning.

Here is an example. Suppose a question asks how the final line of Tennyson's Ulysses conveys the speaker's determination.

A weak answer: "The line is very determined. It shows Ulysses wants to keep going."

A stronger answer: "The final line conveys Ulysses' unwavering determination through a series of four infinitive verbs, 'To strive, to seek, to find, and not to yield'. The verbs build in momentum, and the closing negative, 'not to yield', shows that he refuses to surrender to old age. This reinforces the poem's central idea that a meaningful life involves constant striving, even as death approaches."

Notice that the second answer names the feature, quotes economically, and explains the effect. It does not simply repeat the question.

Questions about tone

Tone questions are very common. Give a precise tone word, then justify it with evidence from the diction or punctuation. "Angry" is acceptable; "contemptuous" or "indignant" is often better if it fits. In Donne's The Sun Rising, for instance, the opening insult "Busy old fool" sets up an irreverent, mocking tone towards the sun. If a question asks about a change in tone, you must describe both the tone before and the tone after, and identify where the shift happens. For more on choosing tone words, read Tone vs Mood in Poetry.

Questions about imagery and figures of speech

When a question asks about an image or a figure of speech, identify what is being compared to what, and then explain what the comparison suggests. In Sylvia Plath's Mirror, the mirror becomes a lake, and an old woman is pictured rising towards the woman who looks into it, "like a terrible fish". A good answer would explain that the simile makes ageing seem monstrous and threatening, something that surfaces from the depths whether she wants it to or not. The word "terrible" is doing a great deal of work, so comment on it.

Quoting well

Keep quotations short and relevant. Copying out a whole line or stanza wastes time and suggests you are not sure which words matter. Choose the two or three words that carry the effect and place them in quotation marks. How to Quote Effectively in Poetry Answers goes into this in more depth.

Common pitfalls

  • Paraphrasing the lines instead of analysing them.
  • Naming a device without explaining its effect.
  • Using vague words like "interesting", "nice" or "powerful" without saying why.
  • Writing about the poet's life when the question asks about the language.
  • Giving one point for a question that clearly wants more.
Exam tip: if you are stuck, ask yourself "So what?" after every sentence. If your sentence does not answer that question, you have not finished the point.

Practise with real questions

The best preparation is regular, timed practice with past-paper style questions, followed by honest marking against a memo. Start with the prescribed poems you know best, then move to unfamiliar ones. The How to Analyse a Poem method will help you prepare your thinking before you start writing.

If you would like structured practice with model answers, the member PowerPoints include exam-style contextual questions for each prescribed poem (see the options).

Go Further with Video Lessons

Step-by-step video analyses and exam-style PowerPoints for every prescribed poem and setwork.