Comparing two poems is a different skill from analysing one. When you analyse a single poem, you follow its argument. When you compare, you build an argument of your own about how two poems relate. Many learners know both poems well and still lose marks because they write two separate mini-essays joined by the word "similarly". This post shows you how to compare properly.
Start with a genuine point of connection
A comparison needs a reason. Before you write anything, ask what the two poems share and where they part ways. The connection is usually one of these:
- A shared theme, such as belonging, mortality, love or power.
- A shared situation, such as a speaker addressing someone directly, or a person looking back on the past.
- A shared technique, such as an extended metaphor or a dramatic monologue.
- A contrast in attitude towards the same subject.
The best comparisons usually combine similarity with difference. Two poems might both explore belonging, but one through anger and the other through affection. That tension is what gives your answer something to say.
A worked example: Trespasser and For Oom Piet
Take Trespasser by Tatamkhulu Afrika and For Oom Piet by Finuala Dowling. At first glance they seem to have little in common. One conveys the humiliation of being made to feel like an intruder in your own country under apartheid; the other is a warm, personal tribute to an older Afrikaans man.
Look closer, though, and both are about how South Africans relate to one another across the lines of race, language and history. Afrika's poem gives us the experience of exclusion, held in with controlled anger. Dowling's poem shows respect and affection reaching across a cultural divide, signalled by the word "Oom" itself. Both use a personal, first-person voice to say something larger about the society around them. Now you have a thesis: both poems explore belonging in South Africa, but where Afrika exposes the pain of exclusion, Dowling offers an image of connection.
The free common themes page on these two poems develops this pairing in more detail, and Identity and Belonging: Strangers Forever & Trespasser shows how Afrika's poem works with a different partner.
Two ways to structure a comparison
The alternating structure
Each paragraph deals with one point of comparison and discusses both poems within it. For example, paragraph one compares the speakers, paragraph two compares the imagery, paragraph three compares the tone and endings. This is usually the stronger structure because the comparison happens in every paragraph.
The block structure
You discuss the first poem fully, then the second, and draw the links together in the second half and conclusion. This can work in a short answer, but in a longer essay it often turns into two separate discussions. If you use it, make sure your discussion of the second poem constantly refers back to the first.
Exam tip: if every paragraph mentions both poems, you are comparing. If a paragraph mentions only one, check that it still serves your comparative argument.
The language of comparison
Small linking phrases do a great deal of work. Vary them so that your comparison sounds deliberate rather than mechanical:
- To show similarity: "likewise", "in a similar way", "both poets", "this echoes".
- To show difference: "whereas", "by contrast", "while", "on the other hand", "unlike".
- To show nuance: "although both... the effect is quite different", "to a lesser degree", "more subtly".
Notice that the strongest comparisons are often about degree and effect, not just presence. Saying "both poems use imagery" earns very little. Saying "both poets ground abstract ideas in concrete images, but Ferlinghetti's are playful and theatrical while Karibo's are rooted in everyday ritual" earns a great deal more.
A second pairing to practise
Superstition and Constantly Risking Absurdity make an excellent practice pair. Both deal with forces beyond rational control: inherited belief in Karibo's poem, and the risky leap of artistic creation in Ferlinghetti's. Their tones are very different, which gives you plenty to discuss. The common themes page for this pair is a good starting point, and you can read more about Ferlinghetti's central image in The Poet as Acrobat.
A comparison checklist
Before you hand in a comparative answer, check that you have:
- Stated a clear thesis that names both poems and the link between them.
- Discussed both poems in most or all of your paragraphs.
- Supported each point with short quotations or precise references from both poems.
- Explained the effect of the techniques, not just named them.
- Ended with a conclusion that says what the comparison reveals, rather than repeating your introduction.
For more help with the essay format itself, read How to Write a Poetry Essay for IEB English, and for keeping your evidence sharp, see How to Quote Effectively in Poetry Answers.
Go Further with Video Lessons
Step-by-step video analyses and exam-style PowerPoints for every prescribed poem and setwork.
