All Articles

Poetry Skills

Metaphor, Simile and Conceit: Know the Difference

By Kate · · 4 min read

Metaphor, simile and conceit are all ways of comparing one thing to another, and they lie at the heart of poetry. Learners usually know the basic difference between a metaphor and a simile, but the conceit and the extended metaphor cause more confusion. More importantly, many answers identify the comparison correctly and then stop. This post clarifies the terms and shows you how to analyse comparisons properly.

Simile

A simile compares two things using "like" or "as". Because it announces itself as a comparison, it keeps the two things slightly apart. The reader is aware that one thing is only being likened to another.

In Sylvia Plath's Mirror, the woman who looks into the mirror sees an old woman rising towards her from its depths, "like a terrible fish". The simile compares the arrival of old age to a creature surfacing from dark water. It suggests something hidden, unwelcome and frightening, which reflects the woman's dread of growing older.

Metaphor

A metaphor makes a direct comparison by stating that one thing is another. Because there is no "like" or "as", a metaphor often feels more forceful and complete than a simile.

In the same poem, the mirror becomes a lake. This metaphor deepens the idea of reflection: a lake has depths, and things can be hidden in it and rise from it. The shift from flat glass to deep water suggests that self-examination goes deeper than surface appearance.

Tatamkhulu Afrika's Trespasser also depends on metaphor. The speaker is made to feel like a trespasser in his own country, and this idea represents the racial exclusion enforced under apartheid. The word carries legal and moral weight, suggesting someone who has no right to be where he is, which is exactly the injustice the poem exposes.

Extended metaphor

An extended metaphor is a comparison that is developed over several lines or across an entire poem. Rather than appearing once, it is explored in detail, with different aspects of one thing matched to aspects of another.

Lawrence Ferlinghetti's Constantly Risking Absurdity compares the poet to a high-wire acrobat throughout. The poet, like the acrobat, performs above an audience, risks falling with every step, and must have perfect timing to catch Beauty. Each detail of the circus act corresponds to something about the risks of writing poetry. When you analyse an extended metaphor, trace how it develops and what each part of the comparison adds.

Conceit

A conceit is a special kind of extended metaphor: an ingenious, surprising and often far-fetched comparison that demands intellectual effort from the reader. Conceits are especially associated with the Metaphysical poets of the seventeenth century, of whom John Donne was a leading figure.

In Donne's The Sun Rising, the speaker develops the outrageous idea that the lovers' bedroom contains the entire world. He claims that she is all countries and he is all kings, and he tells the sun that by shining on their bed it shines everywhere: "This bed thy centre is, these walls thy sphere." The comparison is witty, exaggerated and argued with mock-logic, which is precisely what makes it a conceit rather than an ordinary metaphor. If you want to explore how this poem's idea of love compares with Rossetti's, read Love Poems Compared: The Sun Rising and Remember.

A quick summary

  • Simile: compares using "like" or "as".
  • Metaphor: states that one thing is another.
  • Extended metaphor: a metaphor developed over several lines or a whole poem.
  • Conceit: an extended metaphor that is especially ingenious, surprising or intellectually daring.

How to analyse a comparison

Identifying the comparison is the starting point, not the finish line. Use these steps:

  1. Name the two things being compared.
  2. Identify the points of similarity: what qualities of the second thing are being transferred to the first?
  3. Consider the connotations of the chosen image.
  4. Explain how the comparison supports the poem's tone or theme.

Here is the difference this makes:

  • Weak: "Plath uses a simile when she says 'like a terrible fish'."
  • Strong: "By comparing the old woman who rises in the mirror to 'a terrible fish' surfacing from the depths, Plath presents ageing as something monstrous and inescapable, emerging whether the woman wants it to or not. This conveys her deep anxiety about losing her youth."

Common mistakes

  • Calling every comparison a metaphor, even when "like" or "as" is used.
  • Calling every extended metaphor a conceit. A conceit should be strikingly clever or unexpected.
  • Explaining what the comparison is, but not what it suggests.
  • Forgetting to link the comparison to the bigger meaning of the poem.
Exam tip: if you are unsure whether something is a metaphor or an extended metaphor, describe it as a comparison and explain how far it is developed. The analysis matters more than the label.

Comparisons and imagery

Figurative comparisons are one of the main ways poets create imagery. To see how to write about images in depth, read Imagery in Poetry: Beyond "It Creates a Picture". For an overview of all the main devices, see Literary Devices: A Matric Poetry Toolkit.

Mastering these distinctions will make your answers sharper and more precise, and it will help you appreciate just how much thought poets put into a single comparison.

Go Further with Video Lessons

Step-by-step video analyses and exam-style PowerPoints for every prescribed poem and setwork.