All Articles

Poetry Skills

Speaker vs Poet: Why the Difference Matters

By Kate · · 4 min read

"In this poem, Carol Ann Duffy steals a snowman." If you have ever written a sentence like that, this post is for you. One of the quickest ways to make your poetry answers more precise is to understand the difference between the poet, who wrote the poem, and the speaker, the voice that is talking inside it. They are not always the same, and treating them as the same can lead you into real misreadings.

What is the speaker?

The speaker (sometimes called the persona or the poetic voice) is the "I" of the poem, or the voice telling us what we hear. The poet is the real person who chose every word, the form, the images and the line breaks. The poet creates the speaker, in the same way that a novelist creates a narrator.

Sometimes the speaker sounds very close to the poet's own voice. Sometimes the speaker is clearly a character. And sometimes the speaker is not even human.

Three kinds of speaker

The character speaker

In a dramatic monologue, the poet invents a character and lets them speak. In Duffy's Stealing, the speaker is a thief who steals out of boredom and loneliness, including a snowman that falls apart. Duffy is not confessing to a crime; she is giving voice to an alienated character so that we can see the world through their eyes. Saying "Duffy feels bored and empty" would be a serious misreading.

In the same way, Tennyson is not Ulysses. In Ulysses, the ageing hero speaks of his restless desire for one final voyage. We know from the poem's context that Tennyson wrote it after the death of his close friend Arthur Hallam, so it is reasonable to suggest that the poem channels some of the poet's own struggle to keep going. But the voice we hear is still Ulysses'. You can read more about this form in The Dramatic Monologue: Ulysses and Stealing.

The non-human speaker

In Sylvia Plath's Mirror, the speaker is the mirror itself, which claims to be perfectly truthful and without preconceptions. The whole effect of the poem depends on this choice. We watch a woman searching for herself in the glass, but we see her only through the cold, apparently objective eye of the mirror. If you write "Plath says she is silver and exact", you miss the point of the personification entirely.

The speaker close to the poet

Some poems do seem to come from the poet's own experience. Trespasser explores the feeling of being made an intruder in your own country, and Tatamkhulu Afrika knew apartheid's racial classification at first hand. Even here, it is safer to refer to "the speaker" when you discuss the voice of the poem, and to bring in the poet's life only where it genuinely illuminates the poem.

Why the difference matters in the exam

Keeping the speaker and poet separate helps you in several ways:

  • Accuracy: you avoid crediting the poet with views or actions that belong to a character.
  • Irony: you can see when the poet wants us to judge the speaker. Shelley's Ozymandias is a good example: the boastful inscription belongs to the tyrant, but the poem as a whole mocks that pride.
  • Better analysis of technique: questions often ask why the poet made a choice. The poet chooses the speaker, the form and the images; the speaker simply speaks.
  • Tone: it is easier to describe the speaker's tone precisely when you think of the speaker as a person in a situation. Our guide to tone versus mood builds on this.

Useful phrases

Use the speaker to talk about what is said and felt, and the poet to talk about craft:

  • "The speaker pleads with her beloved to remember her..."
  • "Rossetti uses the volta to show the speaker's change of heart..."
  • "Duffy's choice of a colloquial, conversational voice makes the thief disturbingly believable..."
  • "Through the persona of the mirror, Plath explores..."
  • "The poet allows the speaker's pride to undermine itself..."

Notice how, in Christina Rossetti's sonnet Remember, you can discuss the speaker's movement from pleading to generous release, and then credit Rossetti with the Petrarchan structure that mirrors that change. Both are true, but they are true of different people.

When can you mention the poet's life?

Biography is useful when it sheds light on a specific feature of the poem. It is not useful as a substitute for reading the words on the page. A good rule:

  1. Start with what the poem itself says and does.
  2. Bring in context only if it deepens your reading of a particular line, image or attitude.
  3. Never assume that the speaker's experiences happened to the poet unless you know this to be well established.
Exam tip: when in doubt, write "the speaker". It is never wrong to refer to the voice of the poem as the speaker.

This small habit makes your writing sound more mature and more precise. For a broader method of working through a poem, see How to Analyse a Poem, and keep A Matric Poetry Glossary handy for terms like persona, apostrophe and dramatic monologue.

Go Further with Video Lessons

Step-by-step video analyses and exam-style PowerPoints for every prescribed poem and setwork.